Conflicting reports of what happened next, from 4 p.m. to dusk, led to the controversy.
Of the 585 to 605 men present, the Union losses were reported as 277 to 297 dead. It is obvious that the race of the soldiers was a consideration in the casualties. Of the black members of the garrison, only 58 (around 20%) were marched away as prisoners; 168 (almost 60%) white soldiers were taken.